Electric or Gas Smoker Which is Better? A [really] Simple Choice

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases!
Share on:

There are many types of smoker machines you will find in the market. However, electric smokers and gas smokers are one of them.

Both are better in their aspects. You cannot differentiate them easily. But when it comes to choosing which is better, gas or electric smoker, this will be challenging for you.

What do you think, electric or gas smoker, which is better? I know this is one of the most confusing topics. So, people get confused when they go to buy a smoker machine.

In this article, I will give you a comparison between electric smokers and gas smokers. It will help you as your buying guide. So, let’s get started:

1. Best electric smoker

Our Top Pick
Masterbuilt MB20070210 Analog Electric Smoker
  • Built-in temperature gauge
  • Temperature control is easy with analog dial
  • Wood chip tray slides out for easy ash removal
  • Three chrome-coated smoking racks
  • 1,500-watt heating element for even, consistent smoking

2. Best gas smoker

Our Top Pick
Cuisinart CGG-180T Petit Gourmet Portable Tabletop Propane Gas Grill
  • Portable gas grill with 145-square-inch grilling area and foldaway legs
  • Cooks 8 burgers, 8 steaks, 6 to 10 chicken breasts, or 4 pounds of fish
  • Powerful 5,500 BTU stainless-steel burner and even-heating porcelain-enameled grate
  • Aluminum legs and stabilizing feet set up in seconds; integrated lid lock keeps lid secure
  • Pronounced briefcase-style carrying handle; weighs 13.5 pounds

Comparison between electric smokers and gas smokers

After reading the comparison, you can easily decide which is better for an electric or gas smoker. Because you will get the massive difference between them that can help you to improve your cooking. So, let’s start the comparison:

1. Ease of Use

People love those products that are easy to use. Electric and gas smokers are both easy to use. However, the electric smoker using process is more accessible than the gas smoker. Because gas smokers’ temperature fluctuates very quickly. So, you need to pay extra attention.

2. Quality of food

Why do people buy a smoker? To make food tastier. So, food quality is essential. In that case, an electric smoker can give you better results than a gas smoker.

An electric smoker can give you consistent quality food, whereas gas smokers don’t have consistency. Yes, its taste is good, but the quality is not the same as an electric smoker.

3. Versatility

You can’t estimate the electric smoker. Because you can cook your food at a low temperature in the electric smoker. But the gas smoker can go up to 204 degrees Celsius. If you add an offset smoker, its temperature goes up to 260 degrees Celsius.

With this temperature, you can quickly cook roast perfectly. So, a gas smoker is better than an electric smoker in terms of versatility.

4. Temperature range

An electric smoker’s temperature range goes from 38-153 degrees Celsius, whereas the gas smokers’ temperature has come up to 79-204 degrees Celsius.

However, gas smokers can reach a higher range of temperature. But the electric smoker has the ideal temperature range for cooking.

Besides, if you want to cook food at a higher temperature, gas smokers are the best option for you.

5. Cooking capacity

Electric smokers and gas smokers both have a wide range of cooking capacity. But a gas smoker has more capacity than an electric smoker.

However, if you need any large unit of cooking capacity, a gas smoker will be a good fit for you. And you can choose a vertical or horizontal offset in your gas smoker.

6. Reliability

Reliability is one of the essential things for smokers. Because people want to buy those things which are reliable. In that case, both gas and electric smokers are reliable in their perspectives.

But if you need to repair a smoker, then a gas smoker is easier to fix. Electric smokers are also made with suitable metals. But it’s very costly to repair

7. Initial cost

The price depends on the features, benefits, and many more important things. However, an electric smoker is more costly than a gas smoker. The entry-level cooker wants a budget-friendly smoker.

If you want a low-budget smoker, you can try gas smokers. But when you don’t have any budget problems, definitely go to the electric smoker.

8. Maintenance Cost

Maintenance is another crucial task for your smokers. It can increase your smoker’s lifespan. However, you need to clean and repair every damaged part. Otherwise, it will be ruined quickly.

Moreover, an electric smoker is known as a modern smoker. Its parts are very tight and fit. So, its maintenance cost is not so high. But gas smokers take more time because of its structure. And its maintenance cost is very high.

9. Effects of Bad weather

If you are a regular electric smoker user, you must be thinking about bad weather. Because bad weather can directly affect your electric smoker.

But the gas smoker is less affected than the electric smoker in the bad weather. Gas smokers are also affected by some conditions, such as heavy rain or wind. So, you must be cautious in the bad weather.

10. User

Electric and gas smoker users are different. If you are a beginner in cooking, an electric smoker will be your best partner. But the gas smokers are not suitable for beginners. It is mainly designed for experienced grillers.

11. Ongoing cost to run

It will depend on your local electricity rate. But this will vary from city to city and county to country. If you use the solar panel, your ongoing cost is $0 per hour for both smokers.

But if you use electricity, it will take $0.06-$0.10 per hour for both smokers. But electric smokers use more electricity than gas smokers.

12. Popularity

Most people try to find famous smokers before buying. In that case, gas smokers are more popular than electric smokers. Gas smokers dominate in the online forums. In short, gas smokers have a considerable fanbase.

Ending Thoughts- Electric or Gas smoker which is better?

There is a lot of confusion between electric smokers and gas smokers. People are repeatedly asked that electric or gas smoker which is better in a few online forums. You can’t decide the best quickly. You need to know a detailed comparison between them.

However, I have already shared every vital comparison between electric and gas smokers that will help you decide before buying a smoker.

Worthy of mentioning, don’t go to buy a product influenced by anyone. Try to read every necessary detail of the product and go for buying. Because electric smokers and gas smokers are both important assets for you. So, enjoy your quality meals with the best smoker.

Leave a Comment